Most Recent
Descartes, Doubt, and What It Means to Know
What if everything you thought you knew could be questioned? In 1641, René Descartes tried exactly that in his Meditations on First Philosophy, doubting everything he could in order to rebuild knowledge on a certain foundation. Philosophers Tony Bolos and Jamie Collin unpack what Descartes was doing, why skepticism is so hard to answer, and what all of this has to do with people “deconstructing” their faith today.
Along the way, they clarify how philosophers use the words belief, knowledge, truth, and justification. They explain the evil demon and brain-in-a-vat thought experiments and argue that Descartes's lasting lesson is that knowledge does not require certainty. Reflecting on your beliefs is good, but doubt alone does not undermine what you know.
In this episode
· Why Descartes is called both the first modern philosopher and the last scholastic
· How Cartesian geometry helped make the scientific revolution possible
· Belief versus knowledge, and why believing something strongly does not make it true (featuring Tony’s dad and the circus gorillas)
· What it means for a statement to be true
· Two versions of the skeptical challenge: underdetermination and “you can’t rule it out”
· “I think, therefore I am” as Descartes’ one fixed point
· Passive and active faith deconstruction, and Descartes as the “first deconstructionist”
· Why rational belief, religious or otherwise, does not demand total certainty
Mentioned
· René Descartes, Meditations on First Philosophy (1641)
· Plato, Republic (the allegory of the cave)
· Galileo
· Karl Popper on revising theories
